Reddit is still one of the most-searched words on Google, and Google is still crawling the site as hard as ever. So why did Reddit lose more than 1 million search referrals a week in October? Matt Southern at Search Engine Journal reports what Reddit's leaders say is behind it.
TL;DR: Reddit's CEO says Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode are the biggest part of why its search traffic is falling. Reddit's response is to test a logged-in-only experience outside the US.
📉 Reddit Lost Over 1 Million Search Visits a Week in October
Reddit reported a meaningful drop in search referral traffic in the third quarter, and it sped up in October. In October alone, the drop averaged more than 1 million referrals per week.
The hit landed mostly on logged-out and web visitors. But it also reached logged-in and app users, because many of them find Reddit or come back to it through search.
Reddit says that if the trend continues, its daily active uniques could fall by a low-double-digit percentage in Q4, from a base of 130 million. In the US, logged-out daily users already fell from 30.1 million to 27.3 million between Q2 and Q3.
🔎 The CEO Blames AI Mode, but It's Still a Hypothesis
CEO Steve Huffman points to Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode as the biggest part of Reddit's working hypothesis. His reasoning is that AI answers sit at the top of the page and push the regular results further down. Fewer people scroll that far, so fewer people click.
The key word there is hypothesis. Reddit hasn't proven it, and the claim comes from the company that lost the traffic. But the pieces that fit are worth noting: demand for Reddit hasn't dropped, and Google's crawling hasn't slowed.
Huffman also said AI Mode does not drive traffic, for Reddit or, as far as he knows, for anyone else. Treat that as one company's view, not a measured industry number.
Reddit has a second suspect. It thinks Google may be ranking machine-translated content lower, which would hit its international traffic hardest.
🔐 Reddit's Answer Is to Ask Visitors to Log In
In Q4, Reddit plans to fully test a logged-in-only experience in select markets outside the US. The goal is to find the right boundary: how much a visitor coming from search can see before being asked to log in. It isn't necessarily a hard paywall.
Traffic isn't the only reason. Logged-in users give Reddit better signals for ad targeting, and most scraping of its data happens through logged-out access. Reddit also cited emerging regulations.
Huffman admits the move will likely trade reach for engagement. The numbers explain why that may be an easy trade for Reddit: logged-in and app users account for over 80% of its monetization, and Q3 revenue grew 53% year over year to $895 million.
🛠️ What to Do When Search Traffic Gets Less Reliable
Check Whether Your Own Clicks Are Falling
Open Search Console and compare impressions and clicks over the last few months. Look for pages where impressions hold steady but clicks drop. That is the pattern Reddit is describing, and your data will tell you whether it applies to you.
Give Visitors a Reason to Come Back Directly
Reddit can ask people to log in because it has a huge community behind it. Most sites can't do that, but you can still build a direct line. An email list, a free tool, or a resource people bookmark all do the same job: they don't depend on a Google result to bring the person back.
Stay Skeptical of Optimization Hype
Reddit's COO, Jen Wong, said she is pretty skeptical of generative engine optimization, or GEO. That's the practice of optimizing content for AI model outputs. She said Reddit is fairly resistant to manipulation and that GEO is not part of its advertiser partnerships today.
That doesn't mean AI search doesn't matter. It's a reminder that nobody has a proven playbook yet, so useful content is still the safer bet.
Hit reply
Have your Search Console clicks dropped while impressions stayed flat? Reply and tell me which kinds of pages took the hit first.
One thing I'm thinking about: Reddit already has a data licensing deal with Google, and its traffic still fell. Huffman says Reddit is in active discussions with Google and OpenAI about licensing, and that not doing a deal is one possible outcome.
A business relationship with a search engine isn't the same as a traffic guarantee. The sites that look steadiest next year may be the ones people already come to on their own.
Till next time,



